Starship Modeler - The complete information source for modelers who build sci-fi, fantasy and real space subjects


Birds of a Feather: Three Hawks Compared


By Brian Miller - images & text © 2005

HOTO Models
Scale: 1/72
Parts: 16 resin pieces
Instructions: One page, double sided, with decent diagrams and a good paint guide.
Decals: None
Molding Quality: 5
Detail: 4
Accuracy: 4
MSRP: $40.00 USD (~$50.09 CAN/ Ä 32.96 EUR) available from MOnsters in Motion
Overall Rating: 3 - not recommended - see review


WARP
Scale: 1/72 - in scale with the WARP Eagle and Product Enterprise eagle, as well as other aftermarket accessories. Should build up to about 10Ē/254mm long.
Parts: 43 (if I counted correctly) most in resin, with a dozen or so white metal parts and several pieces of styrene strip for detailing
Instructions: One page of instructions, copied from Airfix kit
Decals: None
Molding Quality: 8 -a couple of bubbles in lousy areas
Detail: 7
Accuracy: 7
MSRP: $95.00 USD (~$118.96 CAN/ Ä 78.30 EUR) available from Federation Models (USA) and Comet Miniatures (Europe)
Overall Rating: 7 - see review


Space Fighter Buteo
Scale: 1/48 - , in scale with the Replicas Unlimited Eagle Should build up to about 17Ē long.
Parts: Ī25 resin, with several pieces of styrene strip for detailing
Instructions: Nice photo-instructions
Decals: ALPS-printed waterslide by JBOT.
Molding Quality: 8
Detail: 9
Accuracy: 9 - a point off for the nose cone
MSRP: Out of Production
Overall Rating: 9 - see review

[HOTO boxart]


[Warp's Boxart]

The release of a new kit of the Space:1999 Hawk fighter in 1/48 provides an interesting opportunity to do an out of box comparison of several kits of the same subject currently available.

The Mark IX Hawk, seen in only one Space:1999 episode has become much sought after; if you have an Eagle, you need a Hawk as a companion. Martin Bower designed the ship for the episode "War Games", using a similar design aesthetic to the Eagle. Airfix released a kit of the Hawk during the 70s; while rare, it was somewhat more accurate than the available styrene Eagle kits, as I remember. Of course, it is even more rare now.

The Kits

The first kit, purchased from Monsters in Motion, is recast directly from an Airfix kit, and minimizes assembly. When I bought the kit, MIM's web site did not identify it as being cast from the Airfix kit, but does now. The casting is pretty good, no visible bubbles or pits, and just a bit of flash. The box the kit comes in actually has the picture from the Airfix box on it.

In comparison, the kit from WARP has a nice photo of the completed kit. Ironically, the instructions for this kit are based on xeroxed copies of the Airfix kit instructions. The instructions look to be adequate, but not extensive.

[Click to enlarge]

^ HOTO's kit
Image: Main body, top view

Image: Underneath

Image: Side view of the noe

Image: Detail pieces

Image: Spine and other fine detail


^ Warp's kit
Image: Bagged parts

Image: Detail pieces

Image: Body, underneath

Image: Main engines

Image: Nose

Image: Big bubble

Image: Instrucions

[Click to enlarge]

^Space Fighter Buteo
Image: Auxiliary engines

Image: Body, top view

Image: Underside

Image: Main engine

Image: Nose, side view

Image: Detail parts

Image: Instructions

[Click to enlarge]

^ Main engine comparison
Image: Nose shape comparison

Image: Spines


^ Three command pods

The castings look pretty good from a standpoint of detail included. the resin is not the more brittle stuff WARP typically uses. There is some amount of flash, and the pour stubs will need to be removed. There are a limited amount of bubbles, but a particularly large one at the rear of the main fuselage will take a bit of work to fill. Many of the smaller parts are connected, or still have pour stubs attached.

Two different main engines are included. One is similar to the previous kit and obviously comes from the Airfix kit, but the second looks to be more accurate. Much more detail is present on this kit than the MIM version, and looks to be several steps above it in accuracy. The metal parts have a lot less flash and clean up necessary than the WARP Eagles.

The Space Fighter Buteo kit is, of course, much more detailed than the other two kits, being of larger scale. The box doesn't have any pictures or anything; but more importantly, does have multiple large FRAGILE labels. The pieces are cast very well, with the larger ones being hollow cast. My pieces did not have any problematic thin areas, and no pits or bubbles show up any where. The two piece main engine is easily the most accurate of the three. This kit actually has fewer pieces than the WARP kit.

The instructions are a couple of pages, and are based on photograph illustrations, which is a big improvement over most resin kits. Decals, printed by JBOT, include the windows and anti-glare panels for the nose, vrious stripes, three different versions of the Alpha Moonbase logo, and what appear to be crew patches. All three kits come very well packed in lots of peanuts and bubble wrap; the Space Fighter Buteo kit protects the spine with a cardboard tube or plastic box, which is a nice precaution.

Accuracy

I had read some concerns about the accuracy of the nose section; I have included some photos of the various models, as well as reference pics from the original. It looks to me like none of the kits hit the nose right on, although the Space Fighter Buteo kit seems the closest. the proportions are right, and just a couple of angles and corners are off. Itís admittedly a hard shape to create. Iíve also included a couple of photos of the main pieces of the Space Fighter Buteo next to my nearly finished Replicas Unlimited Eagle for comparison.

Overall, the Space Fighter Buteo kit looks to be the most accurate and detailed, naturally, because itís the largest scale. The WARP kit was a bit surprising; it is much better in comparison to the WARP Eagles, and of reasonable detail. It should build up into a nice model. The MIM kit is of little use, unless you absolutely need an exact copy of the Airfix kit and canít afford eBay prices for a real one. After seeing the other two kits, I regret buying it, especially after discovering it's basically a recast.

Conclusions

I am most partial to the Space Fighter Buteo kit, because itís larger and so beautifully detailed, as well as being a companion to the Eagle. But I was pleasantly surprised by the Warp kit, and look forward to completing that as a smaller version; perhaps I will make that one part of a diorama or figure out some landing gear.


Many thanks to Brian's wallet for providing the review samples. Manufacturers and retailers, interested in getting your wares reviewed and publicized on a site averaging 3500+ readers a day? Contact us!

Please note that the opinions expressed in this article are those of the reviewer.

Read other reader's reviews of these kits

Submit your own review

Go back up | Other Sci-Fi Index | Starship Modeler Home | Site Map | Feedback

This page copyright © 2005 Starship Modeler™. First posted on 10 June 2005.